Forum

not really convinced by Alan's comments about not "tapping" players. I note the careful wording that he uses so it may not be a "direct committee" approach but that doesn't preclude an approach being made by "a friend". As other posters have indicated, approaches HAVE been made to players in other clubs but perhaps this is not the place for naming names. Having said that, this is the "same old same old" debate - used to be directed at Derriaghy now its CI, again. I wonder if the most successful league side will be going down the road of oversea player next season? - their "machine" continues to turn out home grown talent with young Ally Shields being a revelation this season. I have seen some talented lads down the club so perhaps the CI "machine" needs a couple more years, but maybe,like the English Premier League, they don't wnat to wait for home grown success. My experience of Mr. McMillan was somewhat limiteed but I did form a view about his attitude. I was spectating at Ballymena on a wet Friday when CI were struggling and Craig, having been out, was reading the paper in a different part of the ground when I felt that he should have been with his team-mates trying to encourage them but perhaps that wasn't his role. I'm sure there were will be postings about his contribution but as I say, it was only my opinion. My other issue with parachuting guys in is the effect on "home" players who lose their place on the team. There are guys I see walking round the boundaries who have been lost to playing because of this. And lets come clean about this - they can be called Development officers, player coaches, etc. when the reality is that, with notable exceptions such as Solanky & Merchant, they are hired guns brought in to try to win the Premier title and the incredible amount of prize money! Perhaps someone in the know will let us know how much the Champions actually win. Or maybe its the entry into Europe!!. Recession? WHAT RECESSION?

To: INT ER ESTED

Yes sure we can talk about whatever tomorrow night at the dinner. This is my first post in quite a while.
Looking forward to tomorrow night.
Macky

Clarence: CIYMS certainly keeps the site hits moving!

RE - Scotty

I think you should maybe sit in the shade for a while as clearly the sun has clearly affected your judgment.

What I said in my post was that at AT LEAST one other person BESIDES the 'Pro' gets paid in every Premier League Club and in a lot of cases '4,5,6' as you state in your post.

As for your father, commendable but in the end he turned out like a number of Premier League Cricketers, a mercenary lured by £££

Wake up

Micheal...Any chance of joining you at the 19th. Had enough of all of this!!!! Pity some people cant take another mans word on things!!!!!

Re CI Man -

Don't think anyone has a problem if you pay one man to play for your club - personally I think people have a problem when you (appear) to pay 4/5/6 people to play for you ! My dad played for one club during the best years of his playing life despite having many offers to play for other teams - he did however by his own omission take a cheque when by his own admission he was "dun" and could offer our our club no more !!

Alan,

With all due respect you must be new to the post ???????????

Mackey(or Alan as you now prefer to be known !)

I would beg to differ with your statement that you as a club don't approach schoolboys - rather you wait for them to express an interest in joining you !I am a senior and longstanding playing member of a club and my son(s) is/are already being given assurances of things he/they may be given if he/they join CI ! Happy to chat to you at the City Hall tomorrow night about it !

Re, Alan CI

I'm sorry, but I simply don't believe you - and i would suggest many don't either...

Bottom line is - if any club has declared open season on other clubs schoolboys - then in my opinion that is an incredible new low
Furthermore, if there is proof of incentives being offered to schoolboys then surely the NCU should be taking action...?

As I said in a previous post they are entitled to spend their money however they see fit but it really hasn't bought them that much success. As for their trumpet blowing that we are getting re youth cricket at CI, having watched some of your youth teams and played against both 3's and 4's I think some of you are perhaps getting ahead of yourselves.

The aspiration to have a team of people loyal to a club and willing to do anything playing for you is one that everyone shares. It is however not that realistic. I will commend CI for their long term approach re youth cricket as it is clearly where all clubs should focus their attentions.

I also think that CI are only one of a number of clubs adopting a strategy of paying a lot of people to play for them and a lot of the attention is probably misguided.

At the end of the day cricket should be about enjoyment and fostering a club spirit, as without these success is really meaningless.

R. McKinney : Do you think that certain players haven't let CI know they would be interested in a move either by telling CI themselves or via a 3rd party?! You would be very surprised with how many do!

Florence, did this youngster move to CI or use their offer to broker a better deal with their own club?

Re Alan from CI:

Are you seriously telling us "We dont approach them" (players) statement is true? C'mon, we are all grown up's here!

A couple of the top clubs ie Waringstown and North Down might disagree on the remark i'd imagine.

I have to laugh at all these comments.
There is not one team in the premier league who don't pay at least one other member of the team other than their 'Pro' and some of the figures they are getting would amaze you. Every club is at it
Open your eyes everyone.

Alan CI,

Never worry about all this gossip of paying players, buying trophies and now even chat of free car insurance for prospective recruits !

If your selection panel choose me as their new player/coach for next season, I'll personnally see to it that these malicious rumours are put to bed once and for all.........How ?

Every player on 'my' team, will be there on merit, playing for his shirt/club and proud to be doing so !

And this will start with me !

I won't need paying to do something I love and am very passionate about, plus I have my own car which is already legally insured; but I may accept a small donation towards the cost of travelling from Moira to Belfast & return if this is acceptable with your committee.

Fondest regards again to you & all @ CIYMS C.C.

Ok Simon here goes....To begin with I am sorry that you feel the way you do about my club but I can say that no young person has been given any kind of incentive to play for CI, certainly not since I have been Secretary of the club. As for a recruitment policy..We will talk to any person who expresses an interest in coming to play at Belmont, we DO NOT approach them! Our plans are simple, that within the next 5 years we will have a team of CI Men playing in the Premier League and many of these lads are already representing our club at with Ireland, the NCU and the Lords Taverners. I think 200+ kids at CI every week during the season isn't a bad way to start!!