Forum

David - I just think with an average of 13 with the bat and taking 9 wickets (3 of which were v Dundrum)there are others more deserving of a place thats all.

And Robin who would you drop for Regan to come in?? No denying he is one of the best in the country which is why i had him in my 12?! From the 12 i listed why should I have to "get real"?

Whats wrong with Paul McCrum as 12th man? - I believe he has taken wickets and scored some invaluable runs as CI struggle to avoid the drop

re dave work

dave dont think u know too much about local cricket,regan west 12th man,get real.

Thanks Karl - I would have thought after winning the Junior Cup and with a few signings possible if Cliftonville collapse that Section 2 would be appealing.

Sorry Peter. Got too excited and put my finger on the wrong key. Try CSN/CSNI/CSNZ.
Still can't work out what you guys are on about home grown players. Who cares these days? We spend too much time working out our pedigree rather than putting the best team we can get on the field. North County are so far in front of all our clubs we might need to pick a representative team to beat them!

OK Peter I now see there was no point. My point is an "open doors" policy in case that wasn't obvious.
SCNI and North County are the best examples around.

r.e David Somerville

couple of question marks in there for me, Surely Joe Montgomery should be opening the batting ahead of Nelson? How do you explain having Paul McCrum in your 12 for this season??

1. Ryan Haire
2. Jo Montgomery
3. Nigel Jones
4. Mark Hutchinson
5. James Shannon
6. Derek Heasley
7. Peter Shields
8. Ryan Eagleson
9. Greg Thompson
10. David Simpson
11. Allen Coulter

12th man - Regan West

I think that surely this would be the team of the season, all have been top performers this season and surely cannot be denied a position.

Its usually thought that when academy are in a strong position in the league they will not go for it as they are comfortable enough playing section 3 cricket.

Can anyone on the forum shed any light on the Cooke Collegians V Academy match down for 30 August. Acadamy conceded to Cooke Collegians - is this right? Acadamy are going for the league and give a game to Cooke Collegians who are close on their tail!! Seems a bit bizarre to say the least - must be some story behind that one.

Shieldsy - I would have liked you to try the post on CricetEurope for Derriafrica a few years back :-)

David Somerville - I take it you are only including Permier League players? If not, I would imagine that at least 1 of the Kennedy Brothers at Ballymena would be knocking on the door - David ahead of James in my opinion tho. These two aside, I cant see too many others in Section 2 making the side.

NCU Team of Year for your thoughts (Excluding pros, and regular Irish Players)

1. R.Haire
2. L.Nelson
3. N.Jones
4. D.Heasley
5. M.Hutchinson
6. J.Shannon
7. G.Thompson
8. B.Cooper (Wkt)
9. A.Coulter
10. R.Eagleson
11. M.Moreland

12th Man - P.McCrum

Thanks for that 'Mark'
The only point was to help answer a question that was posed by an earlier contributor, asking whether or not there was a club team in Ireland with 7 or 8 home grown players.
I wasn’t making any other point, although you seem to be keen to get yours across!
Shieldsy

Peter what is the point of your local teams analysis on the other channel? The teams that promote local players don't seem to win much as the teams that recruit either locally or overseas do best. North County, Limavady, Brigade, CSNI and North Down being good examples. Recruiting from local clubs is not much different than recruiting overseas players. The world has changed yet the NCU is still trapped in the anti overseas debate that was started in 1979. Let clubs do what they think is best for their own club and get on with it.

congratulations to A. Clements on his questionaire on the future of local cricket currently being digested by all clubs. hopefully if all clubs return these soon we could have some sensible changes in place for this years agm.

Re : Mark Jones

What if CIYMS get relegated? Any other "gossip" or insight to who Waringstown might be interested in? A quality express fast bowler for starters would be nice...